Skip to main content
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $100 BUY MORE, SAVE MORE · Mix & match anything · Up to 10% off · Ends Fri 10AM ET 10 LOCATIONS ACROSS THE NORTHEAST
Store Locations Submissions Sell To Us Help
Cart 0
 Locations
New1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Gary Sheffield #31 PSA 7
Donruss

1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Gary Sheffield #31 PSA 7

$14.99
MIX & MATCHBUY MORE, SAVE MORE
Ends Fri 10AM
2+ items
$14.69
2% off
4+ items
$14.39
4% off
5+ items
$14.24
5% off
BEST VALUE
10+ items
$13.49
10% off
Any products count. Discount applies automatically at checkout.
In Stock — Ships in 1–2 business days
📦 Free shipping over $100
🔒 Secure checkout
Get alerts when cards like this are listed · +100 pts

This 1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Gary Sheffield #31 PSA 7 captures Sheffield's first year with the Milwaukee Brewers in near mint condition. Professionally graded by PSA, this card appeals to collectors seeking an affordable entry point into one of the era's most recognizable rookie designs.

Highlights

  • Rookie Card: Gary Sheffield's official rookie year in the iconic Donruss Rated Rookie subset
  • PSA Grade 7: Near mint condition verified by PSA, with only slight surface wear or minor printing defects
  • Classic Design: Part of the 1989 Donruss Rated Rookie set known for its distinctive border and artwork
  • Card Number: #31 from the 1989 Donruss set

Card details

  • Year: 1989
  • Brand / set: Donruss Rated Rookie
  • Player / character: Gary Sheffield
  • Card number: #31
  • Rookie: Yes
  • Team: Milwaukee Brewers
  • Grading company: PSA
  • Grade: 7

Questions

Is this card professionally graded?
Yes, this card has been graded by PSA and received a grade of 7 (Near Mint).

Is this Gary Sheffield's rookie card?
Yes, this is from Sheffield's rookie year and part of the Donruss Rated Rookie subset.

What does a PSA 7 grade mean?
A PSA 7 indicates near mint condition with only slight surface wear or minor printing defects.

Why shop with Monmouth Cards

  • Rated 4.82 out of 5 by 6,466 verified customers on Judge.me.
  • Authorized retailer and distributor of Topps, Panini, Upper Deck, Leaf, Pokémon, Bandai, Wizards of the Coast, Ravensburger, Konami, Funko, Mitchell & Ness and Franklin Sports.
  • Authorized PSA submission center - drop off your cards for grading at any of our stores.
  • 10 retail stores across New Jersey, Connecticut and Massachusetts, with free local pickup.
  • 100% authentic, guaranteed - sourced directly from the manufacturers, authorized distributors and trusted collectors.

Free Shipping on orders over $100.

Processing: Orders ship within 1–2 business days from New Jersey, with tracking.

Local Pickup: Available at our Monmouth Cards store locations across NJ, CT & MA.

Share:
1989 Donruss Rated Rookie Gary Sheffield #31 PSA 7
$14.99